Wednesday, March 16, 2005

Tolkien & Lewis in "Christian Allegory"

I recently posted this to an email loop I'm on, and received so much positive/appreciative feedback from it that I thought I'd post it here on our blog as well.
**********************
I know this is totally off-topic, but wanted to respond to the following statement as it contained some commonly held misconceptions I thought I'd try to clarify. My intent is not to be argumentative or offensive, but rather just to point to the truth in this matter. I'm sure my opinion in this matter is probably in the minority, but I thought someone might find the following info. interesting just the same. I was certainly glad to come across it years ago. And I do see it as pertaining to our children's education.

>>>>Anonymous wrote; before my older boys were allowed to watch "Lord of the Rings," they were required to read the books in their entirety and explain to me the Christian analogy that the author was getting across. For one, we bought the little paperback called something like "Finding God in the Lord of the Rings" to help. He had to read that, too.<<<< FWIW, I think we can easily do more harm than good when we, as Christians, continue to insist that there are Biblical allegories in Tolkien's trilogy. Tolkien himself denied this supposition while he was alive (see quotes below). I am not worried about unbelievers reading it/watching the movies and getting the wrong idea about God so much; I am more worried about believers reading it and taking some of their theology from it, even if inadvertently.

I read Tolkien's LOTR trilogy, and the Chronicles of Narnia as a child, enjoyed them tremendously. I've read many of Lewis's other books over the years as well...and as I've grown spiritually myself, I've been disillusioned of my prior enamorment with him to a large degree. I've found (from my own readings of his books) that he was an Orthodox man, eventually a member of the Anglican Church, and also that Tolkien was a Catholic (who never claimed to be a Christian). Lewis believed in purgatory, praying for the dead, etc. up to his death. Tolkien and Lewis were human, and their understanding of Christianity was the Bible plus many influences, and all of those were based in mythology, paganism or Greek philosophy at some point. Though I do believe that they were prolific writers, and that our Lord has shared alot of truths through Lewis, I don't think that Tolkien nor Lewis could bear to imagine that something could seem beautiful to a man, and be completely dangerous.

The fruit of the Tree of the knowledge of Good and Evil takes many forms these days, but they are all "good to eat, and desirable for obtaining wisdom." FWIW, we're not going to let our kids read Tolkien, nor the Chronicles of Narnia until we're certain they are familiar with the truth, familiar enough to recognize Tolkien's, and even Lewis's seductive digressions. Then they can make up their own mind about it. Anyways, it just bothers me to see the majority of Christendom embrace these Tolkien books, and movies (which my dh and I watched, aghast that people would let their children view these under the guise of their being a "Christian allegory"- I just couldn't see it, even tried to see where people are coming up w/this!). I think I'd feel more comfortable letting mature teens watch so long as they understood it was ONLY, a fairy tale/myth, in the genre of a modern-day Clash of the Titans or the likes. Anyways, just something to think about...

The question in my mind is does it do a disservice to the Gospel by allegorizing it so heavily, and esp. w/so much paganism peppered in? And I do think so, in some respects... I think John Bunyan's The Pilgrim's Progress is a truly great Christian allegory... But it's just my two cents worth is all...truly, we must each decide for our own families. And yes, for the curious, we do read, enjoy and discuss fairy tales and various fables, etc. I've found my kids do glean alot of spritual parallels in many ways, but we do also wade together through many a falsehood as well. So it shall go with the Narnia and Tolkien books one day... and we shall approach them as such, myth and fairy tales.

Blessings, Beth

******Here's an excerpt from Keepers of the Faith, and for the record, I do not agree with them completely on all of their literary reviews/stances taken concerning many books, esp. as to the value of fantasy. Nonetheless, I found this to be relative and an important aspect to consider as one evaluates the LOTR series, what Tolkien himself had to say about it.

http://www.keepersofthefaith.com/BookReviews/BookReviewDisplay.asp?key=13
As an aside, the following quotes are from Tolkien about his work as allegory: (1) “I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, andalways have done since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence.”(2) “There is no ‘symbolism’ or conscious allegory in my story.” (3) “As for any inner meaning or 'message', it has in the intention of the author none. It is neither allegorical nor topical...” (4) “There is no allegory—moral,political, or contemporary—in the work at all. It is a fairy-story writtenfor adults.” (5) “Is the book to be considered as an allegory?”—The authorreplied, “No. I dislike allegory whenever I smell it.” It is not the intention of this review to delve into the infinite squabbling over the word “allegory” and its meanings and how they relate to Tolkien’s works or those of C. S. Lewis, who also denied an allegorical intent behind his Chronicles of Narnia. We simply wish to draw from this six important points for Christians.

First, God gave us many forms of enjoyment in life. We are to discern (byHis standards) which are good for us. Attempting to allegorize Tolkien’swork is counterproductive to discernment. It will not do for a realChristian to try to stretch reality, and stick a label that says “Christian”on everything in which he would like to dabble (especially when the author,himself, vehemently denies the label). This can be summed up by a quote froma self-professed non-Christian on the subject. He admitted that there are parallelisms that could be construed as allegorical if one should want to doso, and closed with, “Look hard enough and you'll find anything, people.”

Second, discernment by God’s standards teaches us that the works of these men are not only not Christian allegory, but they are not fit for Christian consumption. Consider a few quotes now from God’s Word that deal with the very same topics dealt with in the works of Tolkien (and Lewis).
•Deuteronomy 18:10-12—“There shall not be found among you any one that makethhis son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination,or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch, or a charmer, or aconsulter with familiar spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer. For all thatdo these things are an abomination unto the LORD:” Shall God’s people allowmen like Tolkien or Lewis to bring these practices among them?
• Exodus 22:18—“Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.” Are there any goodwitches before God? Shall we try the terms “white witch” or “white magic” onHim?
• Leviticus 20:6—“And the soul that turneth after such as have familiarspirits, and after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I will even set myface against that soul, and will cut him off from among his people.” DoesGod want us to turn after these things for entertainment? Can we call this“Christian entertainment”? What would God call it?
• Revelation 22:14-15—“Blessed are they that do his commandments, that theymay have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates intothe city. For without are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie.” Paul said,“. . . and what communion hath light with darkness?”—2 Corinthians 6:14. Andwhat communion do Christians have with all these God-forbidden practices andfantasies?
• Revelation 21:8—“But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, andmurderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone:which is the second death.”

How many warnings need God give us to stay away from all this? Is this Christian allegory, or is it just an underhanded,semi-subliminal way to feed our children idolatrous lies.

Third, speaking of children, in one of his denials (above) that his work was allegory, Tolkien stated that it was strictly fantasy for adults. EvenTolkien said that this material was not fit for children—let alone Christian children. Can we spiritualize it, ignore even Tolkien’s own warnings, andthen even subject children to it—with God watching? Did not Jesus say itwould be better to be cast into the sea tied to a mill stone?

Fourth, where do we draw the line between allegory and blasphemy? When we decide to depict the powers of good and evil through images conjured fromour own imagination, we cross an important line. Romans 1:21-23 tells us,“Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neitherwere thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, andchanged the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things.”How shall we view such images offered us from the imaginations of others?Would not be far better for us to simply call these images base entertainment rather than to drag God into the mess, and to say that it is a representation of Him?

Fifth, real Christian allegory will always speak to the spirit in awonderful, godly sort of way. Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress has often broughtme to tears because of Who God is, what He has done for me, and what He intends to do for me. No work that Tolkien has ever produced falls into this category. He stated explicitly that were never intended to do so. The natural, carnal excitement of his books, and now the movie series, appeal tothe carnal, fleshly side of our nature. He stated that as his goal for writing them. What does God say about this as a “Christian” diet? Romans8:7-9 says, “Because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is notsubject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are inthe flesh cannot please God. But ye are not in the flesh, but in the Spirit,if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you. Now if any man have not theSpirit of Christ, he is none of his.” Are Tolkien’s books about right andwrong? God is about right and wrong. What does the thrill of watchingbloodshed (however courageously it is shed), and the butchering of othersfor “right” or “freedom” have to do with a humble spirit, a contrite heart,and the handing of one’s freedom over to one’s Redeemer to be used as He sees fit? Tolkien’s stories do not enrich the spirit. They embolden theflesh. This is not the work of an allegory.Sixth, it is a serious issue to even speak of Tolkien works as allegories.Isaiah 5:20 says, “Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; thatput darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet,and sweet for bitter!” We had better be very careful about trying to forceour own fancies into God’s mold. He will not have it, and He will judge usfor it.

***********excerpt from; http://www.crossroad.to/articles2/rings.htm
Tolkien, himself, assures us that he didn't intend to teach Biblical realitythrough his mythical fantasy. In a 1956 letter he wrote, "There is no'allegory' -- moral, political, or contemporary -- in the work at all. It is a 'fairy-story' ... [written] for adults. 232

Later he continued,"It is, I should say, a 'monotheistic but 'sub-creational' mythology.' There is no embodiment of the One, of God, who indeed remains remote, outside theWorld, and only directly accessible to the Valar or Rulers. These take theplace of the 'gods', but are created spirits...."[8]Yet, many Christians argue that Tolkien's spiritual hierarchy does indeedparallel the Biblical account. Even Tolkien, in spite of his denials, hascompared parts of his myth with corresponding aspects of truth. But the obvious similarities tend to confuse rather than clarify Biblical truth. ForTolkien's myth twists Scriptures enough to change their meanings and muddlethe true nature of God. Like the serpent's temptation in the garden,Tolkien's illusions of truth appeal to human feelings and may lead to deception.For example, his elves and wizards -- the creatures empowered with magicalskills -- enjoy the certainty of unconditional eternal life. But humans donot. Their lives -- with rare exceptions [9] -- must end with their physicaldeath.Instead of the Christian's hope of eternal life, Tolkien's world offers re-incarnation -- but only for a select group. This popular notion defies the Scriptures that tell us that "it is appointed for men to die once, but after this the judgment..." [Heb 9:27] Concerned about this contradiction, the manager of a Catholic bookstore asked Tolkien if he might have"over-stepped the mark in metaphysical matters." Tolkien wrote this response,"'Reincarnation' may be bad theology (that surely, rather than metaphysics) as applied to Humanity... But I do not see how even in the Primary world any theologian or philosopher, unless very much better informed about the relation of spirit and body than I believe anyone to be, could deny the possibility of re-incarnation as a mode of existence, prescribed for certainkinds of rational incarnate creatures."[10]Since Tolkien denies any supposed allegorical link between his myth andBiblical truth, it's not fair to hold his stories accountable to that truth.Nor is it wise to continue claiming that they teach us God's truth.

**********And here's some comments on the above linked review here, w/an excerpt below; http://www.crossroad.to/text/responses/rings.htm
From a "Very Perturbed Person": I am a Christian, and I love God. Lord of the Rings is a story about good versus evil. Now I don't know about Tolkien writing the Lord of the Ring series based on Biblical events, but if you really wanted to compare them, here's a comparison: Gandalf could represent Jesus, he died to save us all,and then rose again. Sauron would definitely be the devil. He's the ultimate evil, and he is conquered later on at the end of the series.

Kjos's response: You illustrate one of the serious problems with Tolkien's myth. ThoughTolkien himself tells us his story should not be read as a Biblical allegory, people continue to believe Gandalf is like Jesus. But that comparison demeans Jesus and distorts the whole meaning of His death and resurrection as well as His redemption and atonement for us.
Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?